A History of the Ministry of Information, 1939-46
Workers were asked: “Are you satisfied or dissatisfied with this way of getting to and from work?”
Sept. - Oct. 1943 | Jan. - Feb. 1943 | Aug. | |
% | % | % | |
Satisfied | 66 | 64 | 81 |
Dissatisfied | 28 | 34 | 17 |
Doubtful | 6 | 2 | 1 |
Sample: | 2944 | 3036 | 3002 |
About the same proportion answered “satisfied” as in January. There is a slight decrease in dissatisfaction, the proportion doubtful being rather higher.
Attitudes are less favourable than in August, 1942. On the whole the results of the present survey approximate fairly closely to those of January. In view of the differences already noted in blackout times and weather these results confirm that the transport situation has become relatively rather worse.
The decrease in dissatisfaction as compared with January is most marked in the case of trams and trains. Of those using trams, 10% are doubtful as compared with 4% in January.
The differences between occupation groups are less marked than in January. The heavy industry group still shows a relatively high proportion dissatisfied. In the case of light manufacture (l) and of mining, attitudes are more favourable than in January. The present inquiry shows average proportions only dissatisfied in these two groups, whereas in January the proportions were relatively high.
In the case of other groups the figures compare fairly closely with those for January.
As in January, S. Wales shows the highest proportion dissatisfied but there is considerable improvement in this region, The north east, north west and south also show some improvement. In East Anglia the proportion dissatisfied is rather higher than in January. Other regions show small differences only.
Analysis by situation of work place (central, inner and outer areas) as in January shows that a slightly higher proportion of those who work in outer areas are dissatisfied, but this difference is only slight.
(No analysis was made by size of town of the January results.)
It will be seen that dissatisfaction is less in smaller than in larger towns. It will be remembered that in smaller towns workers less frequently used public transport services, and that those walking and cycling to work are less frequently dissatisfied than those using public services.
Less than 15 mins. | 15 - 30 mins. | Over 30 mins. to 1 hr. | More than 1 hour | |
% | % | % | % | |
Satisfied | 92 | 65 | 46 | 45 |
Dissatisfied | 6 | 29 | 46 | 48 |
Doubtful | 2 | 6 | 8 | 7 |
Sample: | 712 | 1380 | 686 | 153 |
% dissatisfied Jan. | 8 | 31 | 57 | 62 |
The trend is the same as in January, those taking longer over the journey being more frequently dissatisfied. However, it will be seen that of those with journeys of more than half an hour, smaller proportions are dissatisfied possibly because of the differing blackout and weather conditions at the two periods, since a long journey is more objectionable when made in the cold and darkness than in autumn conditions.
As in January, breakdowns of these results by sex and age show only small differences.
Workers who said they were satisfied, or who were doubtful, were asked: “Is there anything at all you find a nuisance or trying as far as the journey to or from work is concerned?” This question was included, as in January, because it has been found that people are sometimes reluctant to proclaim themselves “dissatisfied”, feeling that they must expect to put up with some inconveniences in war time.
It will be seen that results compare very closely with January.
Altogether 51% in Sept. - Oct. and 57%°in January had some complaint, 28% and 34% respectively at the two period being definitely dissatisfied, and a further 23% acknowledging that they were not altogether satisfied when pressed.
The same sorts of reasons for dissatisfaction were given as before. Vehicles were overcrowded, it was necessary to queue up and wait a long time, there was no transport at the times and places where it was required, services were bad and did not run to time, walking and cycling was often inconvenient, and so on. All these answers are, in fact, different ways of saying that the transport services are insufficient and such reasons were given by 88% of those who were dissatisfied (25% of the whole sample).
Comparison of particular types of answers with those given in January shows some differences, but figures are not given in this report. A detailed examination of the verbatim replies to the question showed that it would be unwise to categorise these replies sharply. In fact the different kinds of complaints very much overlap. For instance, complaints about queuing are often made together with the statement that the reason for the long period of waiting is that the vehicles are overcrowded and that not enough conveyances are available between certain hours in the day.
As might be expected, shortage of torch batteries was not so frequently mentioned as in January, the evenings being lighter at the time of the present inquiry. There is a slight increase in the proportions saying that workers should be given priority.
In the present inquiry an additional question as to the causes of dissatisfaction was asked: “Are you dissatisfied as regards both getting to and from work, or only to work or only from work?”
Dissatisfaction as regards: | % those dissatisfaction | % whole sample |
Both getting to and from work | 43 | 12 |
Only getting to work | 16 | 4 |
Only getting home from work | 36 | 10 |
No information | 5 | 2 |
Sample: | 830 | 2944 |
From these results getting home seems to be a bigger problem than getting to work. One third of the dissatisfaction expressed is concerned only with getting home from work. Whereas altogether 79% of those with dissatisfaction complained about getting home only 59% complained about getting to work.
The numbers dissatisfied in different regions are too small to give very reliable results on this question. However, an analysis made suggests that dissatisfaction with the journey home is higher in the Midlands and the North Eastern region than elsewhere. In each of these two regions, 46% of those dissatisfied complained only of the journey home from work. These results are subject to a margin of error of ± 10% and the statistical significance of the difference is thus somewhat doubtful. However, it may be said that it is probable that the journey home is relatively a more serious problem in these regions.
In London as many complained of the journey to work as the journey home from work. 25± 8% being dissatisfied only with the journey to work and 24 ± 8% being dissatisfied only with the journey home from work. The statistical significance of the difference between London and other regions is a little doubtful, but it is most probable that, compared with other regions, morning transport is more serious a problem in London than elsewhere.